After recent sharp declines, US stock valuations look more attractive, especially compared with bonds. While the current volatility is unsettling, heightened uncertainty about earnings because of the corona virus crisis could create opportunities for long-term investors who distinguish between winners and losers from the shock.
US equities were trading at nearly a 17% premium to their 20-year average before the recent correction. The rally that ground in 2019 had the price / forward earnings ratio of the S&P 500 up to a peak or 19.5 × in mid-February.
How quickly things change. The Fed's emergency 50 – base point rate cut on March 3 underscored mounting concerns about impending macroeconomic damage as the virus spread from China to the rest of the world. Just before the cut, fears emanating from Chinese manufacturing slowdown threatened to destabilize earnings and sent stocks tumbling. In the US, the S&P 500 fell by 12.8% from the market peak on February 19 to February 28, the fastest correction of this magnitude since the global financial crisis.
Falling Bond Yields Flatter Stock Valuations
But bond yields have tumbled, too — and that affects the relative appeal of stocks. Lower rates provide two stimulants for stocks by reducing the cost of borrowing — which can be used by companies to enhance shareholder value — and by making dividends more attractive. Indeed, the 10-year US Treasury yield fell to 1.00% by March 3, versus the S&P 500 dividend yield or 2.01%. In other words, the S&P 500 now yields 101 basis points more than the US Treasury — a gap we've not seen since the global financial crisis ( Display ).
Relative valuations are also illuminating. The valuation of the 10-year US Treasury reached 100 × on March 3, based on the inverse of the current yield, which estimates the price of an investor income for the government bond. That makes the S&P 500 P / E or 17.4 × look very attractive ( Display, left ). Looked at from another angle, the S&P 500 earnings yield or 5.8% dwarfs the US Treasury yield ( Display , right ). And within the US market, investors can find many stocks or companies with strong fundamentals, dividend yields well above 2% and growing dividends to boot.
Finding Opportunities amid the Volatility
Will the economy and earnings hold up? It's still too early to say what coronavirus fallout will affect economic growth and earnings.
While some key US macroeconomic signals are solid, manufacturing reports suggest that many industries are reporting slower deliveries and increased backlogs. With the rate cut, the Fed signaled to the markets that it will act aggressively to contain the damage. Lowering rates can also help cushion the macroeconomic impact of the corona virus, for example, by encouraging mortgage applications and supporting the housing market. We think ultra low rates without a recession should be broadly supportive of the stock market in the mid to long term.
Even though the recent drawdown has been dramatic, we think equity investors should stay the course. In the current environment, active managers can conduct research on individual holdings and investment candidates to determine whether they are positioned to weather the crisis. Many companies have yet to inform markets about the potential effect on earnings. Given the valuation reboot, investors who reach clear conclusions can find new opportunities or add to high-conviction positions at more attractive entry points, and position for a rebound when the uncertainty starts to fade.
The views expressed do not include research, investment advice or trade recommendations and do not necessarily represent the views of all AB portfolio management teams and are subject to revision over time.
Kurt Feuerman —Chief Investment Officer, Select US Equity Portfolios at Alliance Bernstein (AB)
March 04 2020